It didn't start with me spotting AI headshots. It started with a feeling that something didn't look quite right.
On LinkedIn, you've got connections you know, connections you sort of know, and a few you know really well. You know they've just been away on holiday. Then, all of a sudden, there's a shiny new headshot on their profile. Nice clean background, smart look. But it looks an awful lot like the holiday photo you saw a couple of weeks ago.
That's when you start to look a little closer.
Before I go any further: this isn't an anti-AI rant. I use AI all the time. As a solo business owner, it's brilliant. It helps with my admin, my finances, my marketing, and these days even some of the photo editing. It doesn't do the job for me. It speeds up the tasks I'd normally do myself.
But you have to be careful. With AI editing tools, you can change skin tones, or the size of someone's features. Take that too far and the picture no longer looks like the person who sat in front of the camera. That's not the point. The point is to capture the real you.

What gives it away
We've all seen the ones doing the rounds on social media. Six fingers, an ear that's mysteriously gone missing, that sort of thing. Those are easy.
The giveaway for me is usually subtler. The photo just looks too clean. The hair edges are too neat, with none of the stray hairs every real person has. Sometimes there's a slight halo around the head, where one background has been cut out and another squeezed in. It all looks a little bit too perfect.
Real people aren't perfect, and a real photo doesn't pretend they are.
When the photo doesn't match the person
I've certainly met a couple of people who didn't look like their profile photo. Not always because of AI. Sometimes it's an old photo that's been tidied up to look modern, but the face in it is still ten years younger.
For me, this matters more than most. If you read last week's edition, you'll know I rely heavily on what I can see. When I meet someone, online or in person, the first thing I notice is their photo, and that becomes my memory of them. I don't have what they sound like to fall back on.
So when the person in front of me doesn't match the photo, I'm starting from scratch. And I suspect I'm not the only one who feels that little jolt.
Why people choose AI
I understand the appeal. For most people, an AI headshot looks quick, easy and cheap.
But it's the same as anything else in business. Quick, easy and cheap isn't always the best route. If you want a good headshot, it's worth a bit of investment, because whatever you choose, a real photo of you will end up better than anything AI can make.
To be fair to AI headshots, they do get one thing right: they get you visible. Going from a cropped holiday snap to something that looks professional gets you noticed, and at the end of the day, that's what it's all about.
So if you're using one, I'm not going to tell you to take it down today and come and see me. You chose it for a reason. But when you get the chance to do it properly, a real photo will work better for you.
"It'll do"
I know a few people who've used AI headshots and will openly admit they really need to get some proper photos done. The phrase I hear most is "it'll do".
And yes, it'll do. But if you're already noticing it, so are your clients.
One quick check
Honestly, it's a bit awkward. I look at photos all day, so the little details jump out at me. But it's no different from me asking a body shop expert which car has been resprayed. To me, they'd all look exactly as they should.
So start with the obvious. Look for anything that seems out of place: the hair, the edges, the background, the hands if they're in shot. Once you start looking, I'm sure you'll learn to spot them.
Coming up next week
Something close to my heart: what being a trustee at a foodbank has taught me about asking for help, with Christmas just around the corner.
Over to you
Have you ever spotted an AI headshot, or been tempted to try one? Tell me in the comments on the newsletter on LinkedIn. No names, please.
And if you'd like a headshot that's genuinely you, my consultation is free and there's no pressure: book a consultation call.
Thanks for reading,
Shaun

Cover: The River Avon below Warwick Castle.
This post is also published in my LinkedIn newsletter, Stand Out Online. Subscribe there to get each edition.


